Wondering Who Built This Dulcimer
Instruments- discuss specific features, luthiers, instrument problems & questions
Nice find! Interesting dulcimer stand.
Nice find! Interesting dulcimer stand.
Hi Sheryl,
I managed to buy an I.D Stamper dulcimer last week - one of his long scale ones that he used for those A minor slack key tunes like 900 miles and Darlin Cory so my Presnell is going back to the C,c,c tuning that Nettie Presnell used. Hopefully the Stamper dulcimer will be here in a couple of weeks although clearing dulcimers through UK customs is taking weeks at present!!!!
Robin, Good information. I couldn't have said it better. I heard your recording of 900 Miles on your jumbo Presnell, very nice indeed.
The first dulcimer is a Presnell the second looks like a Hicks (he also built mountain banjos) - the large hearts and sloping shoulders make Hicks a possibility. Pricing is difficult because so few of these dulcimers come up for sale. They sort of have two prices - the first price is a players price; basically what the instrument is worth to a dulcimer musician. There are very few of us who actually play, gig and record with these old dulcimers. So the player's pricing for a Presnell is around $350-$450 and the Hicks about the same. So about the price of a new McSpadden. If you can get the Hicks for under $350 I'd certainly be interested if you didn't want to keep it (I have a Presnell). The second price is the collectors price - it is to the long term advantage of a collector to push the purchase price up, so your guess is as good as mine on that score but sometimes these old dulcimers go for silly money if two collectors are bidding.
Personally speaking, I think that wherever possible we should try and keep these old instruments within the dulcimer playing community.
Paula, there is indeed a manual for TablEdit, which you can get in digital form (and print out if you wish -- it's about 150 pages or so), but it is not very user friendly. Stephen Seifert used to have a tutorial available on his website which shows him navigating the software and talking over his computer screen. It is very useful, but I think he has moved it from his website to the Dulcimer School. If you subscribe to the School you can find it there.
I have sometimes learned how to do things in Tabledit just by using Google, but here at FOTMD, we use the Arranging For Mountain Dulcimers Group to pose questions about TablEdit. Answers usually come pretty quickly.
You may already know that you can get a free trial of TablEdit which allows you to compose up to 24 measures, I think. Give it a try. As Robin says, it is not very intuitive and takes a while to get used to, but it is really powerful and once you learn it you can tab arrangements pretty darn quickly.
I wouldn't do that, Dan. I'd rather learn the 'curve'. It was a different situation with my BD, which was built in 2006. Ken Bloom installed them for me. (And I got to see his Workshop. Woo-hoo!) But I appreciate your advice.
If it is a Presnell, changing to mechanical tuners would adversly affect the value of the dulcimer. I currently own six dulcimers with wooden pegs and enjoy them all.
Dan, only a bad experience (Bowed Dulcimer- upgraded to Perfection planetary pegs). You make a good point. Still, I am intrigued.
They don't seem to come with instructions or is there a book you can print?
Tabledit will do the job - but it does take a little time to get to know the programme. It is a very capable programme but takes a bit of time and effort to learn to use it when you first start.
Okay, I have songs I want to put into mtn dulcimer tab. I like the tab that has the regular staff and traditional notes above, and the mtn tab below . In other words, I would like both... What program should I use? tabledit or ABC or what... I need something ease to use as doing this tries my patience!!
Do you have any experience using the wooden tuning pegs, Sheryl? They have a fairly steep 'learning curve' and are troubling for anyone with hand problems (arthritis, etc.).
My next obvious question is, what should I expect to pay for it if I can get it? I'd just like to recognize a deal, if there is one here.
I see what you see Phil. How about these? Same sail, maybe same maker... Raleigh NC, if that helps.
Looks like it could be a Edd Presnell. Here's a link that has one.
Great that you are challenging yourself with your new flute. It does have a beautiful tone and I think you'll be playing it really soon at your Pub gigs, you are sounding good.
I'm seeing this dulcimer at a sale this weekend, and wondering if anyone recognizes it and who may have built it. I can look inside it when the sale starts, but I am hoping to have an idea before I go to the sale. This is the only photo I have. Thanks!
Fair play to you Robin," ya have it in ya."
Thanks Robin - I do like the sound of a well played Irish flute. I've seem Mike McGoldrick play a number of times at festivals and he joined me on dulcimer, Nick on banjo and Mike Harding on mandolin for a couple of tunes outside the beer tent at SFF a few years ago - that was a real treat! Its going to take me a good while to reach my 10,000 hours of practice to play like him
Wow, Robin a warm, lovely tone! Nicely done.
Some wind instruments can sound rather strident but not your flute. :)
I have a new toy
I've long been after a melody instrument for playing at sessions that has a bit of gravitas and would be a challenge to learn. I thought of the fiddle but we already have a fiddler in the house so I looked elsewhere. I'd seen some wonderful Irish D flute players at sessions and gigs and had the idea of learning to play one in the back of my mind. This summer at Shrewsbury Folk Festival I met Jem Hammond. He was running some of the tune workshops and I got the chance to talk with him in the bar. He showed me the different types of flute he played, with keys and without, and suggested I buy a Gary Somers aluminium flute with a delrin head. He had one with him and said that they were well made with a great embouchure hole and solid tone across the octaves.
I emailed Gary in Brazil and he pointed me towards a shop in the UK that had one. Luckily I was working in Canterbury, where the shop was, a couple of weeks ago so I called them and collected the flute. I went straight from Canterbury to Lundy Island for a week's rock climbing. So as well as my dulcimer I also had a new flute to take across to the Island
I carried the flute when walking around the island to various climbing areas and eventually managed to get a scale out of it!!! Getting any noise from it at all was (and still is) a bit hit or miss but my embouchure is starting to come. Having heard Jem play the same model of flute I know that there's bags of rich tone hidden within it and the more I practice the more I'll find.
I love the fact that it is such a kinaesthetic instrument to play and that the tone and intonation come from the player's skill. Like golf, as a beginner you'll hit one or two shots in a round that really feel good and with the flute I'll hit one or two notes that just resonate. I'm hoping that the more I play the more of those good notes I'll be able to hit and the stronger my overall tone will be.
Right now, a couple of weeks in, I'm at the very much a beginner stage. It is doing me good to struggle through the learning process. I've just recorded myself for the first time this morning coffee break so I can assess what I need to work on (mmm.... breath, tone and intonation would be good starters!!!!)
http://k003.kiwi6.com/hotlink/7ox922snmt/Calon_Lan_-_flute_-_5_Oct_16.mp3
You & Lundy Island make a great team, Robin! :)
Your play sounds really good!
Other than standard guitar tuning, Mark also tunes to "Drop D" sometimes to give something of a droning quality to the guitar part. Don't know whether you've ever tried it or not but you might like experimenting if you've not yet played in this tuning.
Terry, my right foot always starts tapping to the beat when i play bones...so I'd say that would not be compatible with driving...lol! =8-o
Lisa, it's kind of ironic that as you were posting your message, I was sitting at my desk, practicing vibrato on a ten hole harmonica. Plan to do "Down in the Valley" tomorow morning at the assisted living home. Great song for vibrato.
In response to what you said about playing and driving, I agree with you, this is not a safe practice. I've been doing it for around two years now, and I must admit that there have been several times when I was a distracted driver. With that said, I don't recommend it. If you are not doing it now, don't do it. However, and you knew this was coming, I doubt I will stop this practice. I do pick my spots though, when not to play, like heavy traffic, school zones, or 45 mph or less. The slower the traffic, the danger goes up.
Now, I'd like to see a video of you playing bones while driving. Not really, but that would be interesting. Hey, when I first got my tabor 3 hole flute, I gave it a go while driving. But then you know the rest of the story.
Terry, I hear you! I think I can add to that list of handy take-along instruments too: the Bones! and...when I get a little better at it...my penny whistle! Both are extremely portable, lightweight, and the bones can be played one-handed... but I can't do either while driving. We're all different, too much traffic here (and deer!)...my brain is one-tracked...requires my whole concentration and both hands while driving, the most I can do is listen to music or talk to my traveling companion.
Susie - last flute purchase... yeah right.
Fantastic version of a great song. You really play it well.
I remember saying this is my final flute after the second one, I am now on number ten. One in every key
Hee hee heee
its very addicting.....but it's a good addiction!!
😜
I remember saying this is my final flute after the second one, I am now on number ten. One in every key
I ordered my 3rd (and likely final) Native American Flute today.
Hmmm that is one line that will be hard to keep to when speaking of Native Americam flutes It's so funny because in the dulcimer community they say "how many dulcimers do you need?" The answer : "just one more!"
hee hee
i can't wait to hear about the next and "final" one you get!!!
Congrats by the way I love my HS flutes!!
Maria
Hi Ken,
What I've found is that it becomes quite a symbiotic relationship between the instruments. The guitar can really work in support of the melody and the dulcimer gives the guitar direction. For Elzic's Farewell I was using primarily one and two fingered chords on the guitar and one 3 fingered inversion. There are some basic chord charts for DADGAD to get you going, like this one here but once you get the concept of playing guitar against drones (like a dulcimer!) you can make up your own chords (or rather partial chords) to suit the piece. I've panned the instruments left and right in the above recording so with headphones on you should be able to pick out what the guitar is doing. Now I'm no great guitarist, I hardly ever play for pleasure and find standard guitar tuning a struggle but I managed to sit down at a friends house the other night and pick out a lot of tunes by ear from DADGAD (Will the circle, You are my sunshine, Shady Grove, OJC, Wayfaring Stranger, Wagon Wheel, I'll Fly Away etc) just as we were sitting and chatting.
I think it is definitely worth a try if your guitarist friend is prepared to experiment a little and step out of their comfort zone!
Sounds really good Robin. I've started trying to convince my guitarist friend to re-tune to DADGAD and see what we can do together...
Congratulations Susie. Exciting times are here for you.
I've had the chance to sit down in my front lounge this evening and record an example of noter drone dulcimer with DADGAD guitar backing. One of the great things about DADGAD is that it is essentially neither major or minor - it is the noter drone dulcimer that actually tells your ears the guitar is playing minor or major chords (which it is not!). There's quite a bit of myth busting going on here - that's a 3 string dulcimer in dorian tuning with wooden pegs and an old Leonard Glen by ear intonated fret pattern. And it is being played noter drone style with guitar. When I first started playing dulcimer the common wisdom was that such a combination was impossible to play in tune. Well what a load of ??**@$%% What I can say is that neither instrument has been anywhere near an electronic tuner - the 9 strings were blended by ear.
Susie, that's exciting! That sounds like a wonderful choice. Though I'm not yet ready for a second flute, I've been contemplating the F sharp, so the info you gave is valuable to me in my musings. When I get more comfortable with my A flute, I think I see an F sharp in my future.
Enjoy!
Thanks Jennifer, I'll posts my thoughts on it after I get it.
I ordered my 3rd (and likely final) Native American Flute today. A High Spirits F#m (Golden Eagle - midtone) in walnut with turquoise inlay. I wanted the F#m due to its popularity in having the traditional, haunting voice (adopted by the Native American community and their key of preference). Also, it is the key that corresponds to the notes on the staff (when you play an F# (as noted on the music staff), it is an F# that sounds). I also wanted to treat myself to one flute with a little flair, so I went with the turquoise inlay. It should look real nice with the walnut. This will be my deepest sounding flute. So, I'm pretty excited to get it.
I was on a rock climbing trip to Lundy Island a couple of weeks ago and met a great guitarist. I had a dulcimer with me so we worked up a few tunes together. He played in DADGAD. Just before the trip I'd started to experiment with the DADGAD as backing for noter drone dulcimer. However on Lundy I had a golden opportunity to play live with a great backing guitarist and really hear the potential of the combination.
It was an absolute delight to work the dulcimer against such a complimentary backing and we fired off fiddle tunes during the evenings we spent staying in the Old Lighthouse on the island. On the last night we ventured to the Marisco Tavern and played a session in the bar. I found a seagull leg bone on the cliffs and using that as a strummer certainly gave my dulcimer a very solid 'voice' in the pub!!!
Since returning home I've been working on my own guitar playing in DADGAD and have been surprised just how intuitive it is to both play melody and back-up for old time fiddle tunes. Now, there could be an 'issue' with old time purists but seeing as how the guitar was a late comer to old time and the fact I've heard some early recordings backed by open tuned guitar DADGAD sits well with me - and it certainly sits well with noter drone dulcimer!
I'll try and record something this week and post it here. But I did wonder if anyone here plays DADGAD and in what context?
Robin
Have a real dulcimer luthier look at it. Normally in such cases we don't raise a whole fretboard for a couple of dips; usually its the other way around -- lower a fret or two. Low spots don't cause intermittant "twanging", high spots would
u need a luthier to examine this dulcimer. a non level fretboard is trouble and the fix could be expensive